Stay ahead of the 2027 growing season — first month free on any plan until January 1st

FlockPlanner
← Blog
Flock Planning · 9 min read

Egg Prices Spike at Thanksgiving. That’s the Week Your Flock Earns Its Keep.

Eggs get expensive in November for reasons that have nothing to do with your hens — and your hens slow down exactly then. The honest math, including the part where year one loses.

Market woman holding a basket of eggs, seventeenth-century painting

Painting: Roelant Savery, Market Woman with a Basket of Eggs (c. 1608–1609) — public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The egg case at my grocery store goes thin on the Tuesday before Thanksgiving. Not empty, thin. The cheap store-brand dozen is gone, the eighteen-count is gone, and what is left is the fancy pasture-raised carton at a price that makes you stand there doing arithmetic on a pie.

That is not a shortage. It is a demand spike with a five-day fuse. Everybody in the country decides to bake in the same seventy-two hours, and the egg supply chain, which is very good at moving eggs on a normal Tuesday, gets asked to move a month of pie demand into one weekend.

If you keep hens, this is the week the math you have been doing all year gets answered. If you do not, this is the week that makes people call a hatchery. Both reactions are worth looking at honestly, because a backyard flock is not a coupon and it is also not a fantasy.

Why November Is Expensive

Eggs are a commodity with a very short shelf life and a very long production cycle, and those two things do not get along. A hen does not lay more because the calendar says November. The national flock is set months in advance, the birds are already at their winter production level as daylight shrinks, and demand just stepped on the gas.

Add the seasonal layer on top of that. Fall is when wild birds move, which is when avian influenza tends to travel, and a single detection in a commercial barn means the whole barn is depopulated. It does not take many of those to move a national price.

The result is a price that is stable for most of the year and then rude for two weeks. That is the pattern, and it is old. It is also the reason people with four hens in the yard feel quietly smug in late November.

What a Real Spike Looks Like

I do not know what your store is charging this week, and neither do you until you get there. But we have a very clear recent example of how far this can go.

Before 2022, the national average for a dozen eggs had mostly sat under two dollars. Then feed costs rose, fuel rose, and avian influenza tore through the laying flock. By January 2023 the national average hit about four dollars and eighty-two cents a dozen, more than double where it started, and in some cities it went well past that. It came back down to around two dollars by that summer, which is its own lesson about how fast these things move.

The number that matters to a household is not the national average. It is what happens to your baking budget in the one week when you buy three dozen eggs on purpose.

The Year an Egg Was a Ration

It has been worse, and not that long ago. In Britain in 1941, with imports cut and shipping under attack, the government put eggs on the ration at one fresh egg per person per week, with a packet of dried egg powder to fill the gap. Expectant mothers and vegetarians got a small extra allowance. Egg rationing in Britain did not end until 1954, nine years after the war was over.

Think about what that means. A government sat in a room and decided how many eggs one person could have. That is how seriously a country treats a cheap source of protein when it becomes scarce.

We are not there. Nobody is rationing your custard. But the instinct behind a backyard flock is the same instinct that made people keep a hen or two in the yard through the war years: if the price is set somewhere far away, own a little of the supply yourself.

The Honest Math of Four Hens

Here is where most flock-keeping articles lie to you, so let me not.

Feed is the only number that comes close to competing with store eggs. A hen eats roughly a quarter pound of layer feed a day. A fifty-pound bag is two hundred hen-days of feed. At twenty dollars a bag, that is about ten cents per hen per day, or roughly thirty-six dollars per hen per year.

A decent layer gives you somewhere between two hundred and fifty and three hundred eggs in a good year, less in her first winter and less again when she molts. Call it two hundred seventy. That puts your feed cost at roughly a dollar and fifty cents to two dollars a dozen, depending on what you pay for feed and how well your birds lay.

That is a real number, and it beats a four-dollar-eighty carton by a mile. Now the other number.

The coop is the cost that ends these conversations. A decent small coop runs a few hundred dollars, a feeder and waterer another fifty, bedding is a recurring cost, and the hens themselves are five to fifteen dollars each depending on age and breed. Add it up and your first year lands around seven dollars a dozen all in, which is worse than the store until you remember that year two is mostly just feed.

So the honest summary is this: a flock is not cheaper than eggs in year one, it is cheaper than eggs in year three, and it is never cheaper than eggs if you count your own labor. What it does buy you is a price that does not move when the news moves, and eggs that are better than anything in the case.

Your Hens Slow Down Right When You Need Them

Thanksgiving lands at almost exactly the moment your flock’s production starts to drop, which is a genuinely inconvenient piece of biology.

Hens lay on daylight. Around fourteen hours of light a day keeps most breeds in steady production, and in November most of the country is well under that. Add a late molt, and the same bird that gave you an egg a day in June is giving you three a week and looking ragged.

You have two honest options. You can let it happen, accept a smaller winter egg supply, and let the birds rest and regrow feathers, which is what their bodies are trying to do. Or you can put a light on a timer in the coop and hold the day length at fourteen hours, which keeps production up but asks more of a bird that is also trying to stay warm.

I let mine rest. I would rather have healthy hens in March than a few extra eggs in December, and the molt is not optional biology. But if eggs are a real part of your food budget rather than a hobby bonus, timed light is a legitimate choice, and it is the single most effective thing you can do for winter production.

What I Do the Week Before Thanksgiving

I collect twice a day instead of once, because cold eggs left in a nest box crack and because I want to know exactly what I have. I write the date on the carton in pencil, oldest in front, and I use those first. A fresh egg holds for weeks in the refrigerator, so the November price does not have to be my November price.

I do not wash eggs I am storing. The bloom on a fresh egg is a barrier, and washing it off shortens the life of the egg. I wash right before I crack it, and I keep the unwashed ones cold and dry.

And I bake the pies on the Monday, not the Wednesday, because a pie that is done is a pie that cannot be ruined by a sold-out egg case.

The Picks, With the Pros and Cons

A quality layer feed — the one purchase that decides your cost per dozen

A complete layer ration at sixteen to eighteen percent protein keeps hens laying through a cold, short-day winter, and the bag price is the single biggest input in your egg math. Buying it in fifty-pound bags and storing it dry is the difference between two dollars a dozen and three.

The honest con: feed prices move with corn and soy, so the bag you bought in September may cost more in January, and a cheap bag with a lot of filler shows up in the yolk and the shell. Why this earns it — you cannot control the commodity market, but you can control the protein level and freshness, and those two things are what actually keep a hen in production when daylight is working against you.
Shop layer feed on Amazon →
Paper egg cartons and a pencil — the cheapest food-safety tool you own

Dating cartons and rotating oldest-first is how a small flock avoids the sad discovery of a forgotten dozen. Paper cartons let the eggs breathe, stack in a fridge door, and cost less per carton than the eggs inside them.

The honest con: paper cartons are harder to sanitize than plastic, and a wet or soiled carton should be composted rather than reused. Why this still earns a spot — you are not running a commercial washing line. You are trying to know which eggs are from Tuesday and which are from three weeks ago, and a pencil on a paper lid does that better than an app.
Shop paper egg cartons on Amazon →

When the Coop Is Your Real Cost

If the reason your eggs cost eight dollars a dozen is that you are still patching a cheap coop every spring, the feed is not your problem. Small coops are usually too small, and a flock that is crowded in January is a flock that gets frostbite, ammonia, and behavior problems that cost more than the coop did.

The Smart Coop is our approved direct program, ten percent off with code FLOCK at smart.coop.farm/FLOCK. It is the buy-once answer if you want a building that vents properly and holds four square feet per hen without you rebuilding it. The honest con is the price, and in a mild climate with three hens you are overpaying for engineering you will not use.

The Ten-Minute Version

Collect twice a day this week. Date the cartons and eat the oldest first. Do not wash eggs you are keeping. Bake early. Expect production to drop with the light and decide now whether you are letting the flock rest or putting a timer on the coop light.

Then do the arithmetic on your own flock instead of guessing. The flock planner will size the flock to your household’s actual egg use and show you the feed bill before you buy birds, and the coop calculator tells you how many hens your building can honestly hold. If you are still deciding whether to start, the flock year guide is the place to begin, and the frostbite post is what to read before the first hard night.

A hen is not a hedge fund. But four of them turn a price you cannot control into a breakfast you can, and that is worth something in the week when everyone else is doing pie math in the egg aisle.

Painting: Roelant Savery, Market Woman with a Basket of Eggs (c. 1608–1609), Städel Museum, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. This post contains affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Disclosure: this post contains affiliate links; we may earn a commission at no cost to you.

Jenna
Written by Jenna
Garden & Flock Editor · November 8, 2026